In short: a notebook is simple but hard to review, a spreadsheet is powerful but slow at the gym, and a notes app is fast but unstructured. A workout tracker app combines the speed of notes with the structure of a spreadsheet, and shows your last performance while you lift.
The comparison
| Method | Good at | Breaks when |
|---|---|---|
| Paper notebook | No phone, no distraction, cheap | You want last week's numbers for one exercise, a trend or a percentage |
| Spreadsheet | Custom formulas, programs, charts | You're typing into tiny cells between sets |
| Notes app | Fast, always on your phone | You want to compare anything; it's just text |
| Workout tracker app | Last time pre-filled, timer, history, charts, maxes | You want something that isn't on your phone |
Why most logs fail
The point of logging is to beat last time. If seeing last time takes effort (flipping pages, scrolling a sheet, searching notes), you'll skip it and repeat the same weights. Whatever you use, make "what did I do last time?" a one-second answer.
Switching to an app without losing progress
- Write down your current working weights and maxes for your main lifts.
- Recreate this week's sessions in the app from its exercise library.
- Enter your maxes so percentage-based sets work from day one.
- Log the next session normally. From then on, last time is filled in for you.
In UrSelf that takes a few minutes, or you can ask Buddy to build the week for you. The free version covers the full log.